Diversity: Proud to be part of it. A personal review of ANSE Journal 5-2 on “Diversity and Multiple Identities”

Verena Bruchhagen (Germany)
June 2022

The text reflects on ANSE Journal 5‑2 from the viewpoint of supervisory reflexivity, arguing that dealing with diversity in supervision means constantly linking structure, action and reflection. Diversity is not approached sentimentally or as a simple celebration of difference, but as a demanding practice of differentiation that includes organisational and societal influences. Bruchhagen highlights how contributions on identity, ambiguity and ambivalence, such as Lea Pelosi’s piece on “identity of self in reflection”, challenge ideas of a fixed, coherent self and instead show identity as something formed in changing constellations, tensions and contradictions. From a supervision perspective, identity cannot result from one‑sided adaptation and repression, and the question becomes how professionals navigate dynamic social and organisational expectations without losing themselves.

The review values the journal’s broad tableau of approaches, from theoretical and methodological discussions to personal and organisational narratives, as a living example of diversity within the ANSE community. This diversity is seen as both content and context for supervision: it reveals multiple professional and personal identities of supervisors and coaches, and invites critical reflection on power, inclusion, exclusion and the frames that shape practice. Making reflexivity the core of a critical diversity approach means being willing to question one’s own position, to tolerate ambiguity and to hold together different levels of experience instead of reducing them to simple categories. Bruchhagen concludes with a sense of pride in belonging to a community that dares to engage in these complex, sometimes strenuous, but fruitful processes of reflection on diversity and multiple identities.

Download PDF
this is an abstract of the full article published in ANSE journal - Volume 6-1.
for extended inspiration you can browse through all ANSE Journals.